The Right Way to Be
Jen’s Take
“I’ve got to tell you the funniest thing that The Big Guy did today.” said my preschooler’s teacher. “He looked around to make sure that nobody was watching before he went into the dress up corner and put on a princess dress. And then he looked a little embarrassed afterward.”
John’s Take
Where am I supposed to go with this? I can go with the politically correct answer to avoid quick judgements and innuendos. Or do I take the honest approach, go with the first word that comes to mind and deal with the judgements later?
1) Honestly I grew up in a very diverse environment and have had many friends who have “batted” for the other team. I know it probably sounds horrible but I hope that TBG ends up staying on my team.
2) Maybe it’s my issue more than Jen’s but I do want to instill some manly-man tendencies into his life. Not the macho-man-beer-can-wingman ways but more of a solid, down to earth, honest, confident man who will be respectful towards women.
3) I will love my son unconditionally forever. But honestly I won’t be able to help but be disappointed should he pick up more feminine tendencies because of how Jen handles these situations.
12 Say it:
Well, I have a very military dad... and i have a son who loves to cook! So, I try very hard not to step on any toes but at the same time encouraging both parties.
I personally don't see the big deal in my son wanting to take cooking classes at the young chef's academy... my dad does... he should be on the football field (and he is returning this year for the second year)... but the kid is in touch with his feminine side...
do I think he'll be gay? nah...i think it's just because the kid is stuck in the house with all girls...he's been forced to play with his sister...
but i have noticed that has he gets older he gets more and more boyish... so i think he'll be fine...much to my dad's pleasure... :)
Wow great post! Worth the wait.
Why is it that the whole dammed if you do and dammed if you don't thing is always the case. However, along those same lines I also thing that your fine if you do and fine if you don't. I think things happen because they happen and as long as your not being excessive either way you don't have much of an effect on them.
I think The Big Guy is going to make a woman very happy one day with all of that cooking practice. And why is cooking a girly thing, anyway? Some of the best chefs are men. I suppose cleaning is a no no too? =oP
I believe you are born into the "team you are going to bat for"....so it really doesn't matter what toys you play with, who your playmates are, and whether or not as parents you try to guide your kids towards a gender-specific role. You are what you are. If our kids don't care what gender their toys and activities are for, why should we?? One of my favorite toys as a little girl was my racing cars set - a very boy specific toy. I wanted it because my male cousin had one & it was fun to play with. Toys are toys. The gender specific crap is all about marketing. Let kids play with whatever they want!!
I really don't think that there is anything wrong with boys playing with "girl's" toys. A kitchen encouages a boy to cook and understand those sort of household duties. A baby doll in my mind encourages nurturing tendencies. This comes in handy when your son eventually has a family of his own.
Currently, my three year old daughter is obsessed with cars. When we go out to the store or where ever she calls out the name of just about any make of car that she sees. Will this make her masculine? Not so far. When we are at home she is a little dress-up princess just like most girls her age. She likes to wear my shoes around the house, but likes to wear her father's also.
I think that discouraging your kids from playing with certain things, may somewhat break their spirit. Kids are naturally curious about everything. I think the worse thing that could happen if "you did have a batter for the other team," would be to make them ashamed of their natural tendencies.
35 years ago in a conservative new england small town nobody batted an eye when I played with hot wheels instead of barbie, though I know if I'd been a boy doing the reverse it would not have been okay. I hope we've made some progress since then.
This post is really thought provoking (not that the naked poop post wasn't)...but I do have to say that however your son turns out...with regards to homosexuality, it has no bearing on what you two do or don't do.
But on that note, what you do or don't do has direct bearing with how your son learns how to handle situations later on in life.
It's really kind of odd but Allie and I were having this same type of discussion this weekend. We are actually thinking of posting our discussion on here when its our turn again (whenever the hell that is.)
I always like to wait and see what the boys do with the girly things they pick up. When my first son picked up his first barbie I almost reacted. But I stopped and just observed. He made the barbie talk and walk and fall screaming off the book shelf into an imaginary ball of flames (I know this because of the sound effects he made).
My other son was carrying around a purse and wearing dress up high heels. I asked him what he was doing and he said, "I'm collecting worms." His sister's purse was full of muddy, wriggling worms. after we added boys stuff to the dress up box, he stopped wearing the high heels and chose the pirate boots (which traditionally have high heels, don't they?)
P.S. There is NOTHING girly about a boy cooking. Hasn't anyone watched The Iron Chef?
Probably just a phase. With a sister, a lot of boys seem to go through this -- my brothers did!
Unfortunately we probably haven't allowed our son's enough creative play things. They still tend to be violent and agressive rather than creative for boys and too girly and pink if creative. Maybe a dress up box could include a kings outfit or an astronut suit, something non gender specific. I don't think it is a bad thing for dads to participate more in the play time of their son's instilling non violent, creative and masculine role models.In early days boys spent more time out in the wilderness with their fathers, and not all their time with sisters, mothers and female teachers. I do agree however that children should ber allowed to play with whatever they want. Cooking and raising children is something all husbands & fathers need to know. Wearing dresses maybe not, but not a big deal for a child.
If our three boys have taught us anything, it is that they are going to be who they were meant to be and there isn't a whole lot you can do about it. When we first adopted our two oldest, the social workers told us in hushed tones that the younger brother liked to dress up like a girl and we shouldn't be alarmed by it. A few weeks later I found him dancing in front of my mirror dressed in a minidress he made out of a garbage bag. I wasn't sure whether to laugh or be horrified. As far as I know those cross dressing days are over, but he remains my most effeminate son. The other two wouldn't be caught dead in a dress. I did nothing different with any of them.
You are who you are and that's all there is to it.
....Of course, if my one girl becomes a tomboy she'll have hell to pay because I deserve one girly girl in my testosterone filled world, dammit!! ; - )
All I have to say is that men usually make the best chef's.
If you're concerned that he wants a purse, maybe persuade him to get a backpack for camping or something instead.
Post a Comment
<< Home